IJDS / Archive / Volume 15, Issue 4

OPEN ACCESS ARTICLE

Climate stress, fortress conservation and cultural rupture in rural communities of the Makana Local Municipality, Eastern Cape, South Africa

Mandlenkosi Maphosa, Kablan Antoine Effossou, Philani Moyo

Fort Hare Institute for Social and Economic Research (FHISER), University of Fort Hare, 50 Church Street, East London 5200, South Africa

IJDS 2026; 15(4): 497–518.
DOI: 10.63212/IJDS25120801

Read full article (PDF)

Abstract

This article investigates the synergistic impact of accelerating climate stress and fortress conservation on the cultural well-being of historically marginalised communities in the Makana Local Municipality of the Eastern Cape, South Africa. This study develops and applies an author-derived analytical framework that integrates cultural ecology and critical political ecology to examine how climate stress and fortress conservation interact in shaping community experiences. This study utilises qualitative empirical data gathered via 58 household interviews, 3 focus group discussions, and 5 key informant interviews across three proximate communities (Alicedale, Kraabos, and Seven Fountains) that are situated on the margins of private game reserves. The data analysis employed a critical political ecology lens to examine how structural exclusion amplifies climatic vulnerability. Findings reveal a layered set of challenges: (1) climate stress destabilises livelihoods and erodes Traditional Ecological Knowledge; (2) fortress conservation imposes rigid spatial exclusion, restricting traditional adaptive pathways and denying access to critical resources; and (3) the convergence of these pressures culminates in cultural rupture and spiritual violence. The study concludes that this convergence produces a compounded vulnerability that structural models fail to capture. It highlights an institutional blind spot in which reserves externalise responsibility for community adaptation, advocating a shift towards restorative climate justice and shared ecological stewardship to mitigate this rupture.

Keywords: Climate stress; Fortress conservation; Cultural rupture; Makana Local Municipality; Eastern Cape; Synergistic

Article history

Received: 8 December 2025 · Revised: 19 May 2026 · Accepted: 25 May 2026 · Published: 13 August 2026

How to cite

Maphosa, M., Effossou, K.A. and Moyo, P. (2026), “Climate stress, fortress conservation and cultural rupture in rural communities of the Makana Local Municipality, Eastern Cape, South Africa”, International Journal of Development and Sustainability, Vol. 15 No. 4, pp. 497-518.

Download citation: RIS · BibTeX

Copyright and licence

© 2026 The Author(s). Copyright is retained by the authors.

This article is available under CC BY 4.0. You may share and adapt the work with appropriate attribution, a link to the licence, and an indication of changes. Third-party material is included unless otherwise indicated in its credit line.

Read the journal’s publication policies