IJDS / Archive / Volume 15, Issue 2

OPEN ACCESS ARTICLE

Beyond conventional land reform: Alternative pathways for redress and spatial transformation in South Africa

Hlanganani Mnguni, Stevem Masvaure, Takunda Chirau, Andiswa Noliqhwa Neku

Centre for Learning on Evaluation and Results-Anglophone Africa, Faculty of Commerce, Law and Management, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa

IJDS 2026; 15(2): 207–224.
DOI: 10.63212/IJDS25081105

Read full article (PDF)

Abstract

This paper critically examines South Africa’s post-1994 land reform programme, exploring its policy intentions, implementation shortcomings, and the growing imperative for alternative and complementary approaches to land access. Despite the adoption of progressive legal frameworks targeting redistribution, restitution, and tenure reform, land reform has yielded limited transformation. Key challenges include bureaucratic inefficiencies, elite capture, inadequate post-settlement support, and persistent tenure insecurity, particularly in communal and urban contexts. The failure to align land reform with broader social and economic development strategies has further constrained its effectiveness and sustainability. In response, this paper explores emerging models such as community land trusts, cooperative ownership, strategic land leasing, land value capture in urban areas, and integrated agrarian reform linked to food systems and rural livelihoods. Drawing on Spatial Justice and Postcolonial Theory, the study advocates for a more participatory, flexible, and context-sensitive approach to land governance. It argues for institutional reform, stronger tenure protections, and enhanced post-transfer support to enable long-term socio-economic empowerment. As a conceptual, literature-based analysis, the paper synthesises existing scholarship rather than presenting new empirical field data. The paper concludes by proposing a recalibrated land reform agenda, one that is inclusive, democratic, and embedded within broader goals of social equity, rural transformation, and spatial justice.

Keywords: Land Reform; Tenure Security; Spatial Justice; Agrarian Transformation; Equitable Access To Land; South Africa

How to cite

Mnguni, H., Masvaure, S., Chirau, T. and Neku, N.N. (2026), “Beyond conventional land reform: Alternative pathways for redress and spatial transformation in South Africa”, International Journal of Development and Sustainability, Vol. 15 No. 2, pp. 207-224.

Download citation: RIS · BibTeX

Copyright and licence

© 2026 The Author(s). Copyright is retained by the authors.

This article is available under CC BY 4.0. You may share and adapt the work with appropriate attribution, a link to the licence, and an indication of changes. Third-party material is included unless otherwise indicated in its credit line.

Read the journal’s publication policies